Quote
Now there's a poorly optimized trash heap of bugs. It easily rivals Stalker. Add to that very long loading times and a horrible, horrible combat system to boot (Why? Why? *cries*).
...
But amazingly, still a lot of fun. I never regretted buying it. I think the parts where the game does well tend to be ignored, and the (admittedly many) poor parts accentuated too much. Your choice, though. I recommend trying the demo first.
Oblivion, although a poor Elder Scrolls, is still a very good game. One I can recommend without having to worry about people being angry with me later.
That doesn't go for Stalker. You might hate it or love it to death (oh, it's so much more hateable or loveable then Oblivion

). The problem is, there's no way for me to tell. Will you like the atmosphere, and the concept of the Zone (try reading Roadside Picnic, although then you might end up disappointed in the game)? Can you appreciate the story? How will you like the AI, how lifelike it can feel and how stupidly it can act? Do you mind a lack of hard RPG elements? Can you use the freedom the game offers? Do you like the not entirely up-to-date but still incredibly realistic, grim and gritty graphics? The music that feels more like it's part of the environment? The careful and thoughtful gameplay that's encouraged (but to be honest doesn't come out well without mods)?
There's an incredible deal of personal preference with Stalker, more then with usual games, imo.
And then there's technical stuff. How well will your system handle? Will you encounter any of the bugs, most of which occur only for some people (I have never experienced it as a buggy game. Crashed only once for example. Others report that it's unplayable due to crashes)?
Just like another reviewer I feel like I should warn people away from the game, but I simply can't stop talking about how awesome it is
Never tried Supreme Commander.